Garage vs Ground-Up ADU: Which Option Fits Your Needs?

Choosing between a garage conversion and a ground-up ADU? Here's what you need to know:

• Garage Conversion:
  • Cost: $100,000 - $150,000
  • Timeline: 6-12 months
  • Size: 200-400 sq ft
  • Pros: Cheaper, faster
  • Cons: Limited design options
• Ground-Up ADU:
  • Cost: $200,000 - $400,000+
  • Timeline: 12-18 months
  • Size: Up to 1,200 sq ft
  • Pros: More design freedom, potentially higher rent
  • Cons: More expensive, longer build time

Quick Comparison:

Your choice depends on your budget, space, local laws, and goals. A garage conversion is faster and cheaper, but a ground-up ADU offers more options and potential value. Consider your needs carefully before deciding.

Related video from YouTube

What Are Your ADU Choices

When it comes to adding an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) to your property, you've got two main options: turn your garage into living space or build something new from scratch. Let's break down these choices.

What is a Garage ADU

A Garage ADU is exactly what it sounds like: you take your existing garage and make it livable. Here's what that usually involves:

• Using the garage's structure (walls, roof, foundation)
• Adding insulation, plumbing, and electrical
• Turning it into a studio or one-bedroom apartment

The big plus? It's often cheaper and faster than building from scratch.

What is a Ground-Up ADU

A Ground-Up ADU is a brand new structure on your property. This option lets you:

• Design it however you want
• Choose the size and features
• Potentially create larger living spaces

The main advantage? You've got more freedom in design, and you might be able to charge higher rent.

Main Differences Between Both Types

What to Think About First

Before you decide, consider these points:

1. Budget: How much can you spend? Garage conversions are usually cheaper, but ground-up builds might be worth more in the long run.

2. Space: Look at your property. Is there room for a new building, or does it make more sense to use what you've got?

3. Local Rules: Check your area's zoning laws and building codes. Some places have limits on ADU types or sizes.

4. Future Plans: Think ahead. Are you after rental income, space for family, or boosting your property value?

5. Property Value: Keep in mind, turning your garage into living space might not add as much value as building a new ADU. Realtor.com says over 90% of homebuyers prefer properties with garages.

"Building an ADU with a pro lets you keep that garage buyers want, while adding more living space." - ADORE Homes

Costs and Budget

Let's talk money. Garage conversion or ground-up ADU? Here's the breakdown:

Garage Conversion Costs

Converting your garage is usually cheaper. Here's what you might pay:

Want a nice kitchen and bath? Expect to shell out $100,000 to $120,000. That's about $240 to $400 per square foot.

Ground-Up Building Costs

Building from scratch costs more but gives you more options. Here's the price tag:

Size matters. Here's how it breaks down:

• 400 sq ft: $120,000 to $200,000
• 500 sq ft: $150,000 to $220,000
• 800 sq ft: $180,000 to $320,000
• 1,200 sq ft: $300,000 to $450,000

Future Money Matters

Think long-term:

1. Maintenance: Both need upkeep, but new builds might cost less at first.

2. Energy bills: New construction often means better energy efficiency.

3. Property taxes: An ADU might bump up your property's value and your taxes.

4. Insurance: Your homeowner's insurance might go up too.

Which Option Pays Off Better?

Let's look at some real-world examples:

A Los Angeles homeowner spent $70,000 on a garage conversion. Now they're raking in $1,500 monthly in rent. That's a potential 25.7% annual return before expenses.

In San Francisco, someone invested $200,000 in a new 600-square-foot ADU. It's bringing in $2,500 monthly, a 15% annual return before expenses.

But here's something to chew on:

"Building an ADU with a pro lets you keep that garage buyers want, while adding more living space." - ADORE Homes

Why does this matter? Over 90% of homebuyers prefer properties with garages. So, a garage conversion might affect your home's resale value.

The bottom line? Weigh your options carefully. Consider your budget, long-term goals, and potential return on investment before making your decision.

sbb-itb-4e754d1

Building Time and Steps

Building an ADU isn't a quick process. Let's look at how long each option takes and what to expect during construction.

Garage Conversion Timeline

Converting your garage is usually faster than building from scratch. Here's a typical timeline:

The whole process? 6-12 months, depending on where you live and how complex your project is.

Ground-Up Building Timeline

Building a new ADU takes longer. Here's what you're looking at:

From start to finish, you're looking at 12-18 months. Construction alone? That's 6-9 months.

Getting Building Permits

You can't skip permits. In California, cities should approve or reject ADU permits within 60 days. But don't hold your breath - it often takes longer.

For garage conversions, you'll need:

• Building permit
• Electrical permit
• Plumbing permit
• ADU-specific permit

Ground-up ADUs? Same permits, plus extras for new construction.

"Talk to contractors when your designer submits plans to the city. Permitting can take months, so get on good contractors' schedules early." - Leah Kabli, ThebestADUbuilders.com

Common Building Problems

Every construction project has its hiccups. Here's what you might face:

1. Unexpected structural issues: Watch out for these in garage conversions.

2. Utility connections: Hooking up water, electricity, and sewage can be a pain.

3. Weather delays: More likely to slow down ground-up builds.

4. Material shortages: Can hit both types of projects.

5. Mid-project changes: Each change can add weeks to your timeline.

Space and Design

Space and design can make or break your ADU project. Let's compare garage conversions and ground-up ADUs in terms of size, design freedom, and layout options.

Size Options

ADU size impacts functionality and value. Here's a quick comparison:

Garage conversions are limited by the existing structure. Ground-up ADUs offer more flexibility, with sizes up to 1,200 square feet in some areas.

California state regulations say, "Local governments may not require ADUs to be smaller than 1,000 gross square feet in size."

Design Freedom

Ground-up ADUs win when it comes to design flexibility:

Garage Conversions: You're stuck with existing walls, roof, and foundation. It's challenging, but can spark creative solutions.

Ground-Up ADUs: It's a blank canvas. You can tailor everything to your needs and preferences.

Leah Kabli from ThebestADUbuilders.com says:

"Standalone ADUs provide greater privacy and independence compared to garage conversions, which may feel more like an extension of the main house."

Making the Best Floor Plan

No matter what you choose, maximize your floor plan. Here's how:

1. Multipurpose spaces

In smaller ADUs, use furniture that serves dual purposes. A Los Altos resident fit an open kitchen, dining, and living room area in just 748 sq ft.

2. Indoor-outdoor flow

A Redwood City homeowner designed a 350 sq ft in-law unit around a shared courtyard. Double French doors create a seamless transition between indoor and outdoor spaces.

3. Vertical space

For ground-up ADUs, consider adding a loft or higher ceilings. It creates the illusion of more space.

4. Smart storage

Use wall cavities between studs for extra storage. Try recessed niches for display or spice storage in kitchens.

Building Rules to Follow

Before you start designing, know these key regulations:

• In California, detached ADUs can be up to 800 square feet, with a maximum height of 16 feet and a 4-foot setback distance.
• Garage conversions typically have no size restrictions. But if they're junior ADUs (JADUs), they can't exceed 500 square feet.
• The Health and Safety Code (Section 17958.1) says the minimum size for an ADU must be at least 150 square feet.

Property Worth and Income

Adding an ADU can boost your property's value and create a new income stream. Let's compare garage conversions and ground-up ADUs in terms of value and income potential.

Effect on House Value

Both ADU types increase property value, but to different degrees:

Ground-up ADUs often add more value. They increase total square footage without sacrificing existing space. In hot markets like California, an ADU can boost a home's value by $200,000 to $500,000.

Rental Income Options

ADUs can bring in solid rental income:

These numbers vary based on location and ADU size. For example, a Los Angeles homeowner spent $200,000 on a detached ADU and now rents it for $2,000 monthly. That's $24,000 a year in rental income.

What Renters Want

Renters often prefer ground-up ADUs because they offer:

• More privacy
• Bigger living spaces
• Newer construction

But don't count out garage conversions. In high-demand areas, a well-designed garage ADU can still attract plenty of renters.

Breaking Even

How long until you recoup your investment? It depends on construction costs, rental income, and property value increase. Here's a rough estimate:

Take this real-world example: A Portland homeowner converted their garage into a studio for $150,000. They rent it for $1,500 monthly, earning $18,000 a year. After one year, they saw a 10% ROI, factoring in both increased property value and rental income.

"Detached ADUs can boost your property value by 20-30% when done right." - Leah Kabli, ThebestADUbuilders.com

Ground-up ADUs cost more upfront but might pay off better long-term. They're usually bigger and can command higher rent.

How to Choose

Picking between a garage conversion and a ground-up ADU isn't easy. Here's how to make the right call:

Check Your Property

First, look at what you're working with:

List Your Needs

What do you want? Let's break it down:

Garage conversions are smaller (200-400 sq ft) and cheaper ($100,000-$150,000). They're faster too, taking 6-12 months.

Ground-up ADUs? Bigger (up to 1,200 sq ft), pricier ($200,000-$400,000+), and slower (12-18 months). But you get more design freedom.

Talk to ADU Experts

Don't go it alone. Get some pros on your side:

Chat with architects about design and structure. Contractors can tell you about building challenges and timelines. And real estate agents? They know the local market and how it'll affect your property value.

"Detached ADUs can boost your property value by 20-30% when done right." - Leah Kabli, ThebestADUbuilders.com

Find Builders on ThebestADUbuilders.com

This site's got your back:

1. Tell them what you want.
2. Check out builder profiles.
3. Look at their past work and credentials.
4. Get quotes from a few different builders.

Making Your Choice

Time to decide:

Think about costs - not just building, but permits and upkeep too. Consider the return on investment. One LA homeowner's $70,000 garage conversion now brings in $1,500 a month in rent.

How fast do you need it? That matters. And don't forget: over 90% of homebuyers like properties with garages.

Lastly, make sure you're following all the local ADU rules and building codes. You don't want any nasty surprises down the road.

Related posts

• ADU Cost Guide: Breaking Down Construction Expenses in 2024
• ADU Project Milestones: Key Phases
• 5 Most Popular ADU Designs for Homeowners in 2024
• Should Your ADU Builder Handle Design, Permitting, and Construction? Here’s What You Need to Know